2011-09-25 Waterhouse -:- Montego Bay

2011-12-04 Montego Bay 3:1 Waterhouse

2012-02-14 Waterhouse 1:1 Montego Bay

2012-10-14 Montego Bay -:- Waterhouse

2012-12-23 Waterhouse -:- Montego Bay

2013-03-21 Montego Bay 1:2 Waterhouse

2013-11-17 Waterhouse -:- Montego Bay

2013-12-15 Montego Bay -:- Waterhouse

2014-04-09 Waterhouse -:- Montego Bay

2014-05-20 Montego Bay 5:2 Waterhouse

2014-09-18 Waterhouse -:- Montego Bay

2014-12-11 Montego Bay -:- Waterhouse

2015-03-22 Montego Bay -:- Waterhouse

2015-05-12 Waterhouse 1:3 Montego Bay

2015-05-17 Montego Bay 5:1 Waterhouse

2015-11-05 Montego Bay 3:1 Waterhouse

2016-01-13 Waterhouse -:- Montego Bay

2016-01-24 Waterhouse -:- Montego Bay

2016-10-23 Montego Bay 2:1 Waterhouse

2017-01-08 Montego Bay 2:1 Waterhouse

2017-03-27 Waterhouse -:- Montego Bay

2017-11-12 Montego Bay -:- Waterhouse

2018-01-25 Montego Bay 2:2 Waterhouse

2018-03-11 Waterhouse 2:1 Montego Bay

2019-03-20 Waterhouse 2:1 Montego Bay

2022-01-16 Waterhouse 2:1 Montego Bay

2022-04-03 Montego Bay -:- Waterhouse

2022-10-30 Montego Bay -:- Waterhouse

2023-02-19 Waterhouse -:- Montego Bay

2023-10-31 Waterhouse -:- Montego Bay

2024-01-23 Montego Bay 2:2 Waterhouse

2024-11-29 Waterhouse 1:1 Montego Bay

2025-01-30 Montego Bay 3:1 Waterhouse

2025-04-03 Waterhouse 1:1 Montego Bay

2025-12-21 Montego Bay -:- Waterhouse