2008-03-04 Youngstown Phantoms -:- Madison Capitols

2008-07-04 Madison Capitols 1:1 Youngstown Phantoms

2009-03-10 Madison Capitols -:- Youngstown Phantoms

2009-07-10 Youngstown Phantoms 1:1 Madison Capitols

2010-06-25 Youngstown Phantoms -:- Madison Capitols

2010-10-30 Madison Capitols 2:2 Youngstown Phantoms

2011-04-30 Madison Capitols -:- Youngstown Phantoms

2011-08-20 Youngstown Phantoms 1:1 Madison Capitols

2012-04-14 Youngstown Phantoms -:- Madison Capitols

2012-08-18 Madison Capitols -:- Youngstown Phantoms

2013-03-13 Youngstown Phantoms -:- Madison Capitols

2013-08-08 Madison Capitols 1:1 Youngstown Phantoms

2014-04-26 Youngstown Phantoms 1:2 Madison Capitols

2014-09-20 Madison Capitols 2:1 Youngstown Phantoms

2015-04-01 Youngstown Phantoms 1:1 Madison Capitols

2015-07-11 Madison Capitols 3:2 Youngstown Phantoms

2016-04-10 Youngstown Phantoms 3:1 Madison Capitols

2017-04-23 Madison Capitols 2:2 Youngstown Phantoms

2017-10-01 Youngstown Phantoms -:- Madison Capitols

2018-04-01 Madison Capitols -:- Youngstown Phantoms

2018-07-11 Youngstown Phantoms -:- Madison Capitols

2019-11-23 Madison Capitols 1:4 Youngstown Phantoms

2021-04-03 Madison Capitols 2:2 Youngstown Phantoms

2021-07-16 Youngstown Phantoms 1:1 Madison Capitols

2021-12-01 Madison Capitols -:- Youngstown Phantoms

2022-03-13 Youngstown Phantoms -:- Madison Capitols

2022-12-31 Youngstown Phantoms 2:1 Madison Capitols

2023-03-11 Madison Capitols 1:3 Youngstown Phantoms

2023-11-12 Youngstown Phantoms -:- Madison Capitols

2024-04-07 Madison Capitols 2:2 Youngstown Phantoms

2024-09-22 Youngstown Phantoms -:- Madison Capitols

2025-02-22 Madison Capitols -:- Youngstown Phantoms

2026-01-17 Madison Capitols -:- Youngstown Phantoms