2012-03-31 New York Red Bulls 5:2 CF Montreal

2012-05-19 CF Montreal 1:2 New York Red Bulls

2012-07-28 CF Montreal 3:1 New York Red Bulls

2013-03-23 CF Montreal -:- New York Red Bulls

2013-05-08 New York Red Bulls 2:1 CF Montreal

2013-07-13 New York Red Bulls -:- CF Montreal

2014-04-05 CF Montreal 2:2 New York Red Bulls

2014-08-23 New York Red Bulls 4:2 CF Montreal

2015-08-06 CF Montreal 1:1 New York Red Bulls

2015-10-07 New York Red Bulls 2:1 CF Montreal

2016-03-12 CF Montreal -:- New York Red Bulls

2016-08-13 New York Red Bulls 3:1 CF Montreal

2016-09-24 New York Red Bulls -:- CF Montreal

2016-10-30 CF Montreal -:- New York Red Bulls

2016-11-06 New York Red Bulls 1:2 CF Montreal

2017-06-03 CF Montreal -:- New York Red Bulls

2017-07-29 New York Red Bulls -:- CF Montreal

2018-04-14 New York Red Bulls 3:1 CF Montreal

2018-09-01 CF Montreal -:- New York Red Bulls

2020-09-27 New York Red Bulls 4:1 CF Montreal

2021-08-15 CF Montreal 2:1 New York Red Bulls

2021-10-30 New York Red Bulls -:- CF Montreal

2022-04-09 New York Red Bulls 1:2 CF Montreal

2022-08-31 CF Montreal -:- New York Red Bulls

2023-04-22 CF Montreal -:- New York Red Bulls

2023-05-20 New York Red Bulls 2:1 CF Montreal

2024-06-19 CF Montreal 2:2 New York Red Bulls

2024-07-17 New York Red Bulls 2:2 CF Montreal

2025-04-26 New York Red Bulls -:- CF Montreal

2025-09-20 CF Montreal -:- New York Red Bulls