2007-05-25 Columbus Crew 2:2 Toronto FC

2007-07-22 Columbus Crew -:- Toronto FC

2007-09-22 Toronto FC 1:2 Columbus Crew

2008-03-29 Columbus Crew -:- Toronto FC

2008-05-17 Toronto FC -:- Columbus Crew

2008-09-13 Toronto FC 1:1 Columbus Crew

2009-03-28 Columbus Crew 1:1 Toronto FC

2009-05-02 Toronto FC 1:1 Columbus Crew

2009-07-25 Columbus Crew 3:2 Toronto FC

2010-03-27 Columbus Crew -:- Toronto FC

2010-10-16 Toronto FC 2:2 Columbus Crew

2011-04-23 Toronto FC 1:1 Columbus Crew

2011-09-10 Columbus Crew 2:4 Toronto FC

2012-03-31 Toronto FC -:- Columbus Crew

2012-08-22 Columbus Crew 2:1 Toronto FC

2012-10-28 Columbus Crew 2:1 Toronto FC

2013-05-18 Toronto FC -:- Columbus Crew

2013-07-27 Toronto FC 2:1 Columbus Crew

2013-08-17 Columbus Crew -:- Toronto FC

2014-04-05 Columbus Crew -:- Toronto FC

2014-05-31 Toronto FC 3:2 Columbus Crew

2014-08-09 Columbus Crew 2:3 Toronto FC

2015-03-14 Columbus Crew -:- Toronto FC

2015-07-25 Columbus Crew 3:3 Toronto FC

2015-10-17 Toronto FC -:- Columbus Crew

2016-05-21 Toronto FC -:- Columbus Crew

2016-07-13 Columbus Crew 1:1 Toronto FC

2016-07-31 Toronto FC -:- Columbus Crew

2017-04-16 Columbus Crew 2:1 Toronto FC

2017-05-10 Columbus Crew 1:2 Toronto FC

2017-05-26 Toronto FC -:- Columbus Crew

2018-03-03 Toronto FC -:- Columbus Crew

2018-06-02 Columbus Crew 3:3 Toronto FC

2020-09-27 Toronto FC 3:1 Columbus Crew

2021-05-12 Toronto FC -:- Columbus Crew

2021-05-29 Columbus Crew 2:1 Toronto FC

2022-03-12 Columbus Crew 2:1 Toronto FC

2022-06-29 Toronto FC 1:2 Columbus Crew

2023-03-12 Toronto FC 1:1 Columbus Crew

2023-08-26 Columbus Crew -:- Toronto FC

2024-07-06 Columbus Crew -:- Toronto FC

2024-09-18 Toronto FC -:- Columbus Crew

2025-08-16 Toronto FC 1:1 Columbus Crew

2025-09-20 Columbus Crew 1:1 Toronto FC