2010-08-06 Philadelphia Union 1:2 Columbus Crew

2010-10-24 Columbus Crew 3:1 Philadelphia Union

2011-08-21 Columbus Crew 2:1 Philadelphia Union

2011-09-17 Philadelphia Union -:- Columbus Crew

2012-04-14 Philadelphia Union -:- Columbus Crew

2012-08-30 Philadelphia Union 1:2 Columbus Crew

2012-09-29 Columbus Crew 3:2 Philadelphia Union

2013-04-06 Columbus Crew 1:1 Philadelphia Union

2013-06-05 Philadelphia Union -:- Columbus Crew

2014-03-22 Columbus Crew 2:1 Philadelphia Union

2014-10-11 Philadelphia Union 2:3 Columbus Crew

2014-10-26 Columbus Crew 2:1 Philadelphia Union

2015-04-25 Columbus Crew 4:1 Philadelphia Union

2015-06-03 Philadelphia Union -:- Columbus Crew

2015-09-12 Philadelphia Union 1:2 Columbus Crew

2016-03-13 Columbus Crew 1:2 Philadelphia Union

2016-06-01 Philadelphia Union 3:2 Columbus Crew

2016-08-24 Columbus Crew 1:2 Philadelphia Union

2017-07-22 Columbus Crew -:- Philadelphia Union

2017-07-26 Philadelphia Union -:- Columbus Crew

2018-03-17 Philadelphia Union -:- Columbus Crew

2018-05-09 Columbus Crew -:- Philadelphia Union

2018-09-29 Columbus Crew -:- Philadelphia Union

2020-09-02 Columbus Crew -:- Philadelphia Union

2020-11-01 Columbus Crew 2:1 Philadelphia Union

2021-04-18 Columbus Crew -:- Philadelphia Union

2021-06-23 Philadelphia Union -:- Columbus Crew

2021-10-03 Philadelphia Union -:- Columbus Crew

2022-04-09 Philadelphia Union -:- Columbus Crew

2022-07-03 Columbus Crew -:- Philadelphia Union

2023-02-26 Philadelphia Union 4:1 Columbus Crew

2023-09-30 Columbus Crew 1:1 Philadelphia Union

2024-08-28 Philadelphia Union -:- Columbus Crew

2024-10-05 Columbus Crew 3:2 Philadelphia Union

2025-05-10 Philadelphia Union 2:2 Columbus Crew

2025-06-29 Columbus Crew -:- Philadelphia Union

2026-04-25 Columbus Crew -:- Philadelphia Union