2011-11-13 Arnett Gardens 1:2 Montego Bay

2012-01-18 Montego Bay -:- Arnett Gardens

2012-04-01 Arnett Gardens 1:2 Montego Bay

2012-04-29 Montego Bay 1:1 Arnett Gardens

2012-10-28 Montego Bay -:- Arnett Gardens

2013-01-13 Arnett Gardens -:- Montego Bay

2013-03-31 Montego Bay -:- Arnett Gardens

2013-11-03 Arnett Gardens 1:2 Montego Bay

2014-02-11 Arnett Gardens -:- Montego Bay

2014-04-20 Montego Bay -:- Arnett Gardens

2014-11-26 Montego Bay -:- Arnett Gardens

2015-01-27 Arnett Gardens -:- Montego Bay

2015-03-01 Arnett Gardens 1:1 Montego Bay

2015-06-02 Montego Bay -:- Arnett Gardens

2015-11-03 Montego Bay 2:2 Arnett Gardens

2016-01-10 Arnett Gardens 2:1 Montego Bay

2016-03-27 Arnett Gardens 2:1 Montego Bay

2016-04-12 Montego Bay 2:1 Arnett Gardens

2016-04-17 Arnett Gardens 2:1 Montego Bay

2016-11-20 Montego Bay -:- Arnett Gardens

2016-11-24 Montego Bay -:- Arnett Gardens

2017-03-09 Arnett Gardens 1:2 Montego Bay

2017-04-25 Arnett Gardens 1:1 Montego Bay

2017-05-02 Montego Bay 1:2 Arnett Gardens

2017-11-07 Arnett Gardens -:- Montego Bay

2017-12-14 Arnett Gardens -:- Montego Bay

2018-03-04 Montego Bay 1:1 Arnett Gardens

2022-02-19 Arnett Gardens 3:1 Montego Bay

2022-05-08 Montego Bay 2:2 Arnett Gardens

2022-11-20 Montego Bay 2:1 Arnett Gardens

2023-03-12 Arnett Gardens 1:1 Montego Bay

2023-11-20 Montego Bay 1:3 Arnett Gardens

2024-02-11 Arnett Gardens -:- Montego Bay

2024-10-08 Montego Bay -:- Arnett Gardens

2025-01-14 Arnett Gardens -:- Montego Bay

2025-03-18 Montego Bay 2:2 Arnett Gardens

2025-05-23 Arnett Gardens 4:1 Montego Bay

2025-12-16 Arnett Gardens -:- Montego Bay