2015-04-11 Philadelphia Union 2:1 New York City

2015-04-16 New York City 1:1 Philadelphia Union

2015-06-06 Philadelphia Union 1:2 New York City

2016-04-23 Philadelphia Union -:- New York City

2016-06-18 New York City 3:2 Philadelphia Union

2017-04-14 Philadelphia Union -:- New York City

2017-06-03 New York City 2:1 Philadelphia Union

2018-08-18 Philadelphia Union -:- New York City

2018-10-28 New York City 3:1 Philadelphia Union

2020-07-09 New York City -:- Philadelphia Union

2021-05-01 Philadelphia Union -:- New York City

2021-08-18 Philadelphia Union -:- New York City

2021-11-07 New York City 1:1 Philadelphia Union

2021-12-05 Philadelphia Union 1:2 New York City

2022-03-19 New York City -:- Philadelphia Union

2022-06-26 Philadelphia Union 2:1 New York City

2022-10-31 Philadelphia Union 3:1 New York City

2023-05-27 New York City 1:3 Philadelphia Union

2023-07-15 Philadelphia Union 2:1 New York City

2024-05-15 Philadelphia Union 1:2 New York City

2024-09-18 New York City 1:5 Philadelphia Union

2025-04-12 New York City -:- Philadelphia Union

2025-10-04 Philadelphia Union -:- New York City

2025-11-24 Philadelphia Union -:- New York City