1998-11-22 Everton -:- Newcastle

1999-04-16 Newcastle 1:3 Everton

1999-11-06 Newcastle 1:1 Everton

2000-03-18 Everton -:- Newcastle

2000-10-20 Newcastle -:- Everton

2001-03-02 Everton 1:1 Newcastle

2001-10-26 Everton 1:3 Newcastle

2002-03-28 Newcastle 6:2 Everton

2002-11-30 Newcastle 2:1 Everton

2003-04-05 Everton 2:1 Newcastle

2003-09-12 Everton 2:2 Newcastle

2004-04-02 Newcastle 4:2 Everton

2004-11-27 Newcastle 1:1 Everton

2005-05-06 Everton -:- Newcastle

2005-11-26 Everton -:- Newcastle

2006-02-24 Newcastle -:- Everton

2006-09-24 Newcastle 1:1 Everton

2006-12-30 Everton -:- Newcastle

2007-10-07 Newcastle 3:2 Everton

2008-05-11 Everton 3:1 Newcastle

2008-10-05 Everton 2:2 Newcastle

2009-02-22 Newcastle -:- Everton

2010-09-18 Everton -:- Newcastle

2011-03-05 Newcastle 1:2 Everton

2011-11-05 Newcastle 2:1 Everton

2012-05-13 Everton 3:1 Newcastle

2012-09-17 Everton 2:2 Newcastle

2013-01-02 Newcastle 1:2 Everton

2013-09-30 Everton 3:2 Newcastle

2014-03-25 Newcastle -:- Everton

2014-12-28 Newcastle 3:2 Everton

2015-03-15 Everton -:- Newcastle

2015-12-26 Newcastle -:- Everton

2016-02-03 Everton -:- Newcastle

2017-12-13 Newcastle -:- Everton

2018-04-23 Everton -:- Newcastle

2018-12-05 Everton 1:1 Newcastle

2019-03-09 Newcastle 3:2 Everton

2019-12-28 Newcastle 1:2 Everton

2020-01-21 Everton 2:2 Newcastle

2020-11-01 Newcastle 2:1 Everton

2021-01-30 Everton -:- Newcastle

2022-02-08 Newcastle 3:1 Everton

2022-03-17 Everton -:- Newcastle

2022-10-19 Newcastle -:- Everton

2023-04-27 Everton 1:4 Newcastle

2023-12-07 Everton -:- Newcastle

2024-04-02 Newcastle 1:1 Everton

2024-10-05 Everton -:- Newcastle

2025-05-25 Newcastle -:- Everton