2014-10-30 Alajuelense 2:1 Cartagines

2014-11-20 Cartagines -:- Alajuelense

2015-02-12 Alajuelense 6:2 Cartagines

2015-04-05 Cartagines 3:1 Alajuelense

2015-09-27 Alajuelense -:- Cartagines

2015-12-09 Cartagines 1:1 Alajuelense

2016-02-28 Cartagines 3:3 Alajuelense

2016-04-24 Alajuelense 3:1 Cartagines

2016-08-07 Cartagines 1:1 Alajuelense

2016-10-16 Alajuelense -:- Cartagines

2017-01-28 Alajuelense 2:1 Cartagines

2017-03-19 Cartagines -:- Alajuelense

2017-09-17 Cartagines 2:2 Alajuelense

2017-11-12 Alajuelense 3:3 Cartagines

2018-01-21 Cartagines 1:1 Alajuelense

2018-03-18 Alajuelense -:- Cartagines

2018-08-05 Cartagines 2:3 Alajuelense

2018-10-04 Alajuelense 2:1 Cartagines

2019-09-01 Cartagines -:- Alajuelense

2019-10-27 Alajuelense 1:1 Cartagines

2020-01-26 Alajuelense 1:1 Cartagines

2020-05-20 Cartagines -:- Alajuelense

2020-11-08 Alajuelense 4:1 Cartagines

2020-12-10 Cartagines 2:3 Alajuelense

2020-12-13 Alajuelense 1:1 Cartagines

2021-02-21 Cartagines 1:1 Alajuelense

2021-04-24 Alajuelense 4:1 Cartagines

2021-08-08 Alajuelense 2:3 Cartagines

2021-10-03 Cartagines -:- Alajuelense

2022-02-10 Alajuelense 3:2 Cartagines

2022-04-24 Cartagines 1:2 Alajuelense

2022-06-26 Cartagines -:- Alajuelense

2022-07-01 Alajuelense 1:1 Cartagines

2022-07-03 Cartagines -:- Alajuelense

2022-07-07 Alajuelense -:- Cartagines

2022-09-29 Cartagines 1:2 Alajuelense

2023-02-22 Alajuelense 3:2 Cartagines

2023-04-25 Cartagines -:- Alajuelense

2023-05-11 Cartagines 2:2 Alajuelense

2023-05-14 Alajuelense -:- Cartagines

2023-09-14 Alajuelense -:- Cartagines

2023-11-12 Cartagines 1:1 Alajuelense

2024-01-28 Alajuelense -:- Cartagines

2024-04-07 Cartagines -:- Alajuelense

2024-08-04 Cartagines -:- Alajuelense

2024-09-22 Alajuelense 2:1 Cartagines

2025-02-03 Alajuelense -:- Cartagines

2025-03-16 Cartagines 1:1 Alajuelense

2025-11-21 Alajuelense -:- Cartagines

2025-11-30 Cartagines -:- Alajuelense

2026-01-22 Cartagines -:- Alajuelense