2010-01-16 Forest Green -:- Gateshead

2010-03-16 Gateshead 3:1 Forest Green

2010-08-21 Forest Green 1:1 Gateshead

2010-11-20 Gateshead 1:1 Forest Green

2012-02-18 Forest Green 2:1 Gateshead

2012-04-14 Gateshead -:- Forest Green

2012-08-18 Gateshead 1:1 Forest Green

2013-02-16 Forest Green -:- Gateshead

2013-09-28 Forest Green -:- Gateshead

2014-03-01 Gateshead 1:1 Forest Green

2014-10-11 Forest Green 1:1 Gateshead

2015-04-18 Gateshead 2:4 Forest Green

2015-09-26 Forest Green -:- Gateshead

2016-03-12 Gateshead -:- Forest Green

2016-08-13 Forest Green -:- Gateshead

2017-02-18 Gateshead 3:1 Forest Green

2024-09-21 Gateshead -:- Forest Green

2025-04-12 Forest Green 2:3 Gateshead

2025-11-15 Forest Green 3:1 Gateshead

2026-02-28 Gateshead 0:2 Forest Green