2006-03-28 Youngstown Phantoms -:- Lincoln Stars

2006-08-19 Lincoln Stars -:- Youngstown Phantoms

2007-04-28 Lincoln Stars -:- Youngstown Phantoms

2007-09-01 Youngstown Phantoms 3:4 Lincoln Stars

2008-05-11 Lincoln Stars -:- Youngstown Phantoms

2008-10-18 Youngstown Phantoms 1:1 Lincoln Stars

2009-02-27 Lincoln Stars 2:1 Youngstown Phantoms

2009-06-26 Youngstown Phantoms -:- Lincoln Stars

2010-02-19 Lincoln Stars -:- Youngstown Phantoms

2010-07-09 Youngstown Phantoms 1:1 Lincoln Stars

2011-05-11 Youngstown Phantoms 2:1 Lincoln Stars

2011-09-14 Lincoln Stars 2:1 Youngstown Phantoms

2012-05-20 Lincoln Stars -:- Youngstown Phantoms

2012-09-30 Youngstown Phantoms -:- Lincoln Stars

2013-05-04 Youngstown Phantoms -:- Lincoln Stars

2013-09-29 Lincoln Stars -:- Youngstown Phantoms

2014-06-15 Youngstown Phantoms 2:1 Lincoln Stars

2014-11-05 Lincoln Stars 1:2 Youngstown Phantoms

2015-04-25 Youngstown Phantoms 1:1 Lincoln Stars

2015-09-12 Lincoln Stars 1:2 Youngstown Phantoms

2016-06-11 Youngstown Phantoms -:- Lincoln Stars

2017-04-08 Lincoln Stars -:- Youngstown Phantoms

2017-09-10 Youngstown Phantoms -:- Lincoln Stars

2018-04-14 Youngstown Phantoms -:- Lincoln Stars

2018-07-22 Lincoln Stars -:- Youngstown Phantoms

2019-11-03 Youngstown Phantoms -:- Lincoln Stars

2021-02-07 Youngstown Phantoms -:- Lincoln Stars

2021-06-12 Lincoln Stars -:- Youngstown Phantoms

2021-10-20 Youngstown Phantoms 2:2 Lincoln Stars

2022-02-05 Lincoln Stars 1:1 Youngstown Phantoms

2022-11-29 Lincoln Stars -:- Youngstown Phantoms

2023-04-16 Youngstown Phantoms 2:1 Lincoln Stars

2023-10-29 Youngstown Phantoms 1:1 Lincoln Stars

2024-05-15 Lincoln Stars -:- Youngstown Phantoms

2024-12-08 Youngstown Phantoms 1:1 Lincoln Stars

2025-05-10 Lincoln Stars -:- Youngstown Phantoms

2025-11-09 Lincoln Stars -:- Youngstown Phantoms