2004-03-13 Everton -:- Cobresal

2004-09-07 Cobresal -:- Everton

2004-11-23 Everton 3:2 Cobresal

2004-11-27 Cobresal -:- Everton

2005-04-21 Cobresal 2:2 Everton

2005-10-01 Everton 3:1 Cobresal

2006-03-10 Cobresal -:- Everton

2007-04-03 Everton -:- Cobresal

2007-09-26 Cobresal 3:1 Everton

2008-01-27 Cobresal -:- Everton

2008-07-10 Everton -:- Cobresal

2009-05-06 Everton 1:1 Cobresal

2009-10-18 Cobresal -:- Everton

2010-04-18 Everton 2:2 Cobresal

2013-02-10 Cobresal -:- Everton

2013-10-05 Everton -:- Cobresal

2014-03-09 Cobresal -:- Everton

2016-11-26 Everton 2:1 Cobresal

2017-04-01 Cobresal 1:1 Everton

2019-09-15 Cobresal 2:1 Everton

2020-02-16 Cobresal 1:1 Everton

2020-12-22 Everton -:- Cobresal

2021-08-04 Everton -:- Cobresal

2021-11-07 Cobresal 2:2 Everton

2022-05-09 Cobresal -:- Everton

2022-10-09 Everton 3:3 Cobresal

2023-03-05 Cobresal 3:2 Everton

2023-08-28 Everton 2:2 Cobresal

2024-05-12 Everton 3:3 Cobresal

2024-10-05 Cobresal 2:1 Everton

2025-05-24 Everton 2:2 Cobresal

2025-11-09 Cobresal 1:2 Everton

2026-04-26 Everton 3:1 Cobresal