2007-06-05 Toronto FC 1:2 New York Red Bulls

2007-08-12 New York Red Bulls -:- Toronto FC

2007-10-04 Toronto FC 2:1 New York Red Bulls

2008-05-01 Toronto FC 1:1 New York Red Bulls

2008-08-17 New York Red Bulls -:- Toronto FC

2008-10-04 New York Red Bulls 1:3 Toronto FC

2009-06-14 Toronto FC 2:1 New York Red Bulls

2009-06-24 Toronto FC -:- New York Red Bulls

2009-10-24 New York Red Bulls -:- Toronto FC

2010-08-11 New York Red Bulls -:- Toronto FC

2010-08-21 Toronto FC 1:4 New York Red Bulls

2011-07-07 New York Red Bulls -:- Toronto FC

2011-10-01 Toronto FC 1:1 New York Red Bulls

2012-06-30 Toronto FC 1:1 New York Red Bulls

2012-09-29 New York Red Bulls 4:1 Toronto FC

2013-04-27 Toronto FC 1:2 New York Red Bulls

2013-07-20 Toronto FC -:- New York Red Bulls

2013-09-14 New York Red Bulls -:- Toronto FC

2014-05-17 Toronto FC -:- New York Red Bulls

2014-06-28 New York Red Bulls 2:2 Toronto FC

2014-10-11 New York Red Bulls 3:1 Toronto FC

2015-08-15 New York Red Bulls -:- Toronto FC

2015-10-14 Toronto FC 2:1 New York Red Bulls

2016-03-06 New York Red Bulls -:- Toronto FC

2016-05-28 New York Red Bulls -:- Toronto FC

2016-09-18 Toronto FC 3:3 New York Red Bulls

2017-05-19 New York Red Bulls 1:1 Toronto FC

2017-09-30 Toronto FC 4:2 New York Red Bulls

2018-07-01 Toronto FC -:- New York Red Bulls

2018-09-22 New York Red Bulls -:- Toronto FC

2020-10-14 Toronto FC 1:1 New York Red Bulls

2020-11-08 New York Red Bulls 2:1 Toronto FC

2021-05-08 New York Red Bulls -:- Toronto FC

2021-07-21 Toronto FC 1:1 New York Red Bulls

2022-03-05 Toronto FC 1:4 New York Red Bulls

2022-06-18 New York Red Bulls -:- Toronto FC

2023-05-17 Toronto FC -:- New York Red Bulls

2023-10-07 New York Red Bulls -:- Toronto FC

2024-06-22 New York Red Bulls -:- Toronto FC

2024-10-02 Toronto FC 1:4 New York Red Bulls

2025-03-22 New York Red Bulls 2:1 Toronto FC

2025-06-25 Toronto FC 1:1 New York Red Bulls